Supreme Court
Supreme Court

MANILA — The Supreme Court (SC) has overturned the dismissal of retired police general Bernardo Diaz, ruling that the administrative proceedings against him over allegations of involvement in the illegal drug trade violated his right to due process.

In a 24-page decision written by Associate Justice Ramon Paul Hernando, the SC First Division found that the Office of the President (OP) and the National Police Commission (NAPOLCOM) committed grave abuse of discretion in handling the case against Diaz, a former Western Visayas regional police director.

The case originated from then-President Rodrigo Duterte’s July 2016 speech identifying Diaz and four other police generals as allegedly linked to illegal drugs. Diaz denied involvement in the drug trade or protecting drug personalities.

The SC ruled that Duterte’s public statements did not constitute a valid verbal complaint under NAPOLCOM rules because they were not supported by a formal complaint-affidavit and relevant documents.

The Court also faulted NAPOLCOM for conducting an investigation before a formal complaint had been filed, with the findings of that investigation subsequently serving as the basis for the administrative charges.

“Here, the Court finds a violation of petitioner’s right to due process because NAPOLCOM failed to observe fairness in handling the administrative case against him. The unfairness manifested in NAPOLCOM’s disregard of its own rules of procedure in the commencement of an administrative complaint and the conduct of investigations,” the SC said.

“Clearly, before any complaint existed, an investigation has already taken place and its findings gave rise to the filing of the complaint,” it added.

NAPOLCOM formally charged Diaz in February 2017 with grave neglect of duty, alleging that he failed to conduct operations against illegal drugs and arrest wanted drug suspects across provincial boundaries.

Diaz maintained that he had directed police units to account for their accomplishments in the anti-drug campaign and ordered the relief and investigation of 23 police chiefs who failed to comply with his instructions.

He also disputed claims that the Regional Anti-Illegal Drugs Special Operations Task Group under his leadership was inactive, saying it had conducted numerous successful operations.

The OP eventually found him liable for four counts of grave neglect of duty and imposed dismissal from service, along with cancellation of his civil service eligibility, forfeiture of retirement benefits and perpetual disqualification from public office.

The SC further found that the OP failed to demonstrate that it had considered the operational reports Diaz submitted in his defense. It also questioned NAPOLCOM’s initial finding of nine counts of grave neglect when the formal charge specified only four. The subsequent reduction of the counts, the Court said, did not cure the due process violation.

Despite procedural defects in Diaz’s petition and his failure to observe the hierarchy of courts, the SC considered the case because it raised issues involving public welfare, public policy and the broader interest of justice.

The Court set aside the OP’s May 10, 2022 decision and March 5, 2024 resolution imposing the penalties against Diaz, who had already retired from the police service.

Leave a Reply

Trending