MANILA — The Court of Appeals (CA) has upheld the conviction of a woman for cyber libel over derogatory Facebook Messenger messages describing another woman as “old, ugly, filthy,” sustaining the P50,000 fine imposed by a Baguio court.

In a 15-page decision, the appellate court denied Ashlyn Akian’s appeal, modifying the ruling only on the provision for subsidiary imprisonment in case she fails to pay the penalty.

The case stemmed from messages Akian sent to their common friend, Ashley, shortly after she was barred from the complainant’s house for allegedly being overbearing.

The complainant discovered the messages after borrowing Ashley’s cellphone. In the conversation, Akian allegedly described her as old, ugly, filthy and a member of a group of mistresses.

Akian argued that the exchange was private and that her remarks referred to another person, not the complainant.

The CA rejected this defense, applying the reasonable expectation of privacy test to determine whether the messages were protected from disclosure.

“the claim of accused-appellant fails under the reasonable expectation of privacy test.”

“Here, although accused-appellant may reasonably have expected that her Facebook Messenger account itself would remain inaccessible to unauthorized persons, the same conclusion does not necessarily extend to messages that she voluntarily sent to Ashley (their common friend),” the court added.

The appellate court explained that sending the messages to Ashley meant voluntarily placing their contents within the latter’s possession and knowledge.

“She could no longer reasonably expect, as against Ashley, that the latter would have no access to, retain no copy of, or otherwise possess the communications deliberately sent to her,” it said.

The CA clarified that private messages do not automatically lose all protection once transmitted, but a sender’s expectation of privacy is limited in relation to the intended recipient.

“This does not mean that every private message loses all protection from the moment it is transmitted. Rather, the sender’s reasonable expectation of privacy is necessarily limited with respect to the intended recipient, who has been voluntarily given access to the communication,” the tribunal added.

The ruling affirmed the Baguio Regional Trial Court Branch 59’s P50,000 fine against Akian for cyber libel.

Leave a Reply

Trending