
MANILA — Parties who fail to raise the absence of barangay conciliation at the earliest opportunity cannot later use it as a ground to seek dismissal of a case, the Supreme Court (SC) has ruled.
In a Decision penned by Associate Justice Maria Filomena D. Singh, the SC Third Division denied the petition of spouses Virgilio and Ma. Estrelita Guasis and affirmed the Court of Appeals’ (CA) ruling directing them to vacate a property they sold to Manuel and Edna DC Millan.
The Millans purchased the property in 2008, but the Guasis spouses continued occupying it despite repeated demands to leave. This prompted the buyers to file an unlawful detainer case to recover possession.
The spouses challenged the sale, arguing that it was void because the Millans had paid only PHP 750,000 of the PHP 8.46-million purchase price, leaving a balance of PHP 7.71 million. They also sought dismissal of the case, citing the parties’ failure to undergo barangay conciliation before bringing the dispute to court.
The Metropolitan Trial Court (MeTC) ruled in favor of the Millans and ordered the spouses to vacate the property. It rejected the barangay conciliation argument because the spouses raised it only in their position paper, not in their answer to the complaint. The Regional Trial Court (RTC) and the CA subsequently upheld the ruling.
The SC agreed, explaining that under the Revised Katarungang Pambarangay Law, or Republic Act No. 7160, parties residing in the same barangay are generally required to undergo conciliation before filing certain cases in court, unless an exemption applies.
However, the Court clarified that noncompliance with the requirement does not automatically bar a court from hearing and deciding a case. A party seeking dismissal on this ground must raise the objection at the earliest opportunity, such as in the answer to the complaint. Failure to do so results in a waiver of the objection.
In the Guasis spouses’ case, the SC found that they raised the issue only in their position paper, making their objection too late.
The Court also discussed the unpaid purchase price and the spouses’ continued possession of the property, which could indicate that the transaction was a contract to sell rather than an outright sale. Under such an arrangement, ownership remains with the seller until the buyer completes payment.
However, the SC said these matters could not be conclusively resolved in an unlawful detainer proceeding and must instead be raised in a separate action before the RTC.
The Court thus affirmed the CA ruling ordering the spouses to vacate the property.
In a dissent, Associate Justice Alfredo Benjamin S. Caguioa maintained that the transaction was a contract to sell and that ownership remained with the Guasis spouses pending full payment.
He noted that the Millans had not completed the purchase price, while the spouses continued to possess the property and pay its real property taxes. Caguioa therefore argued that the spouses had the better right to possess the property.




Leave a Reply