
MANILA — The Office of the Ombudsman has ordered the filing of criminal charges against dismissed Luisiana, Laguna Mayor Jomapher Uy Alvarez over the appointment of an unqualified municipal administrator and the withholding of benefits due to former local officials.
The Ombudsman found probable grounds to charge Alvarez with one count each of violating Sections 3(e) and 3(f) of the Anti-Graft and Corrupt Practices Act, or Republic Act No. 3019, and Article 244 of the Revised Penal Code.
Alvarez was also found administratively liable for grave misconduct and violation of Republic Act No. 10154 over his failure to release the year-end bonuses and cash gifts of former municipal officials Nestor Alcala Rondilla and Ness B. Rondilla, whose terms ended on June 30, 2022.
The Ombudsman imposed the penalty of dismissal from service, with the accessory penalties attached to the order to remain in effect despite Alvarez’s previous dismissal following a separate complaint.
“Clearly, respondent failed to perform his duties under said laws and policies. His inaction is not only unjustified but smacks of ill motive,” the Ombudsman said in its administrative decision.
Alvarez denied the allegations, claiming the complaint was politically motivated and that he had not received the former officials’ letters requesting the release of their benefits. The Ombudsman rejected his defense, describing his denial as unsupported by evidence.
“His mere denial that he did not receive the said letters cannot overcome this presumption, said denial being self-serving and unsubstantiated,” the decision stated.
In a separate case, the Ombudsman ordered the filing of criminal information against Alvarez for allegedly appointing Emmanuel Babaan Villamin as Luisiana municipal administrator in 2022 despite his failure to meet the position’s qualifications.
The vacancy announcement required applicants to have a college degree, first-grade Civil Service Commission eligibility and at least three years of management and administrative work experience.
Alvarez approved and signed Villamin’s appointment less than a month after the position was advertised.
Alvarez and Municipal Human Resource Management Officer I Liza Ludovice Oblenida argued that their roles in the appointment process were merely recommendatory, with the CSC having the final authority to approve or disapprove appointments.
The CSC formally disapproved Villamin’s appointment in March 2023, after which he stopped performing the functions of municipal administrator.
The Ombudsman said the mayor’s appointing authority carried a legal obligation to ensure that the appointee met the requirements for the position.
“Under the LGC (local government code), the power to appoint municipal officials rests exclusively with the Municipal Mayor as the appointing authority which is neither symbolic nor ceremonial as it carries with it a corresponding legal obligation to ensure that any appointment complies strictly with statutory requirements, qualification standards and civil service regulations,” the decision stated.
It also rejected Alvarez’s claim that he was unaware of Villamin’s lack of qualifications.
“Respondent Alvarez cannot feign ignorance of the lack of qualifications of respondent Villamin because aside from knowing the latter personally, the basic requirements for the position are spelled out in the job portal, as embodied in Section 480 of the LGC, which respondent Alvarez ought to know,” the Ombudsman said.
In the related administrative case, Alvarez was separately penalized with suspension for one month and one day without pay. Oblenida was also found guilty of simple neglect of duty and given the same penalty.
The Ombudsman said the suspension penalties would be converted into fines equivalent to the respondents’ respective salaries for one month and one day if they could no longer be enforced because of their separation from government service.





Leave a Reply