MANILA — The House prosecution panel sees no need to present rebuttal evidence in the impeachment trial of Vice President Sara Duterte, saying it remains confident in the strength of its case despite the defense’s presentation of witnesses.

“We don’t see anything to rebut,” House impeachment trial spokesperson and prosecution counsel Atty. Benjamin Tolosa Jr. said in an online interview on Monday.

Tolosa clarified that the decision was not due to difficulty in presenting additional evidence but because the prosecution saw no reason to do so.

“Hindi sa mahihirapan (Not that it would be difficult). More of we don’t see the need to file any rebuttal evidence. When we rested our case, tiwala kami doon sa nabuo namin na kaso (we are confident that we have presented a strong case). And that remains until now. So we don’t see the need to file, to ask that we be allowed to present rebuttal evidence,” he said.

He added that the prosecution welcomed statements made by the defense witnesses, particularly those concerning properties declared in Duterte’s Statement of Assets, Liabilities and Net Worth (SALN).

Tolosa cited the testimony of Engineer John Kenneth Enumerables, assessor of the Island Garden City of Samal, who could not conclusively establish whether the property identified in the Register of Deeds records was the same one declared in Duterte’s SALN.

Enumerables initially testified on November 10 that the property in his documents matched the one listed in the vice president’s SALNs. However, he later failed to give a definitive answer when questioned about conflicting barangay names.

Other defense witnesses mentioned by Tolosa included Davao City Assessor Engineer Jaime Adalin and Atty. Suzette Balucanag-Punay, in-house counsel of Gencorp Industries Inc. and Metro City Chow Foods Corp.

Meanwhile, House prosecutor Rep. Terry Ridon questioned whether the defense’s next batch of witnesses could refute the transactions flagged by the Anti-Money Laundering Council (AMLC).

Ridon said the defense appeared poised to present an expert on the Anti-Money Laundering Act, but doubted that the testimony could contradict the AMLC’s findings.

“Pareho lang din naman ho ‘yung pagtingin ho namin dito sa next set of witnesses. Parang weaknesses pa rin ‘yun pong isasalang po ng depensa. Kasi again, even if you have an AML expert, I don’t think it will ever contradict ‘yun pong findings ng actual Anti-Money Laundering Council, no?” Ridon said.

“I think they will try to showcase na mayroon ho nga — wala namang actual conclusivity ‘yun pong findings ng Anti-Money Laundering Council irrespective of whichever document it is,” he added.

Ridon said he believed the defense would attempt to show that transactions allegedly linked to Duterte and her husband did not raise red flags.

Leave a Reply

Trending