MANILA — Senator-Judge Panfilo “Ping” Lacson said the claim that Vice President Sara Duterte-Carpio made an “honest mistake” in declaring GenCorp Industries Inc. in her Statement of Assets, Liabilities and Net Worth (SALN) could have different implications depending on her intent.

Lacson made the remark Tuesday after former chief presidential legal counsel Salvador Panelo defended Duterte’s inclusion of GenCorp in her SALN, saying it was an honest mistake committed in good faith.

In a post on X, Lacson described an honest mistake as a double-edged sword that could either reveal the truth through an inadvertent slip or reflect a genuine failure to distinguish falsehood from reality.

“‘HONEST MISTAKE’”: It is a double-edged sword. Its meaning depends on the state of mind and intent of the person behind it. It can be an inadvertent slip that exposes the truth, or a genuine blind spot that mistakes falsehood for reality. Ultimately, only the person responsible can say which is which,” he said.

Panelo had argued that Duterte mistakenly listed GenCorp as a business interest in her SALN. His son, Salvador Paolo Panelo Jr., was appointed as the Vice President’s spokesperson.

The issue was raised during last week’s impeachment trial, where Lacson introduced terms such as “loose investment” and “return of capital” to an “impeachtionary” glossary of expressions used during the proceedings.

GenCorp counsel Suzette Punay testified that Duterte received ₱2.14 million from the company between 2022 and 2025 as a return of capital from a “loose investment” in a Jollibee branch in Davao City.

Punay said Duterte invested in the branch in 2007 and that both the branch and her investment were transferred as different companies took over its operations. She also said Duterte had no shareholdings or position in GenCorp from 2022 to 2025.

Lacson, however, questioned the logic of declaring an asset in a SALN if the declarant had never owned it. He said even Punay agreed with his observation.

Leave a Reply

Trending