MANILA— The Office of the Ombudsman has affirmed the six-month suspension without pay of Dalaguete, Cebu Mayor Ronald Allan G. Cesante and five municipal officials over irregularities in the construction of a municipal warehouse on privately owned property.

In a Consolidated Order, the Ombudsman denied the respondents’ motion for reconsideration, finding no sufficient grounds to overturn its August 29, 2025 decision that held them administratively liable for Gross Neglect of Duty.

Aside from Cesante, the officials covered by the suspension were Municipal Assessor and Bids and Awards Committee (BAC) Chairperson Edmund M. Centeno, Municipal Budget Officer and BAC Vice-Chairperson Brenda S. Vergara, Zoning Officer II Essandre P. Amprad, Municipal Government Department Head-I Donald Abraham P. Lara, and Administrative Assistant V Cristina Y. Miranda.

The case originated from complaints filed by Jose Rene E. Moran and Braulio G. Moran questioning the municipal government’s decision to construct a warehouse on a property covered by a Special Power of Attorney (SPA) executed by the heirs of Teodorica Severino and Pedro Moran in favor of Hetzel Moran.

The respondents maintained that they acted within their authority when they initiated and conducted the pre-procurement proceedings, citing a Permit to Enter previously signed by Hetzel Moran.

Cesante, meanwhile, argued that he should not be held responsible for the alleged procurement irregularities because these fell under the jurisdiction of the BAC. He also invoked the ‘Arias doctrine,’ which allows heads of government offices to rely in good faith on their subordinates in processing documents.

However, the Ombudsman rejected the officials’ defenses, ruling that the SPA did not grant Hetzel Moran authority to permit the municipality to enter the property and construct the warehouse.

According to the Office, her authority was limited to executing a Deed of Exchange with the municipal government.

“Respondents Mayor and BAC members should not have merely relied on the Permit to Enter but proactively verified from all the legal heirs if indeed Hetzel Moran had the legal authority to allow the Municipality unlimited access over the said lot,” the Consolidated Order stated.

The Ombudsman stressed that the officials should have verified the validity and completeness of the necessary documents before proceeding with the procurement, awarding and construction of the project.

It also rejected Cesante’s reliance on the Arias doctrine, emphasizing that the principle does not automatically exempt government officials from administrative accountability.

The Office further explained that the respondents failed to present newly discovered evidence or demonstrate any serious error of fact or law that could justify reversing the earlier ruling.

“A perusal of the Motion would show that it does not present any newly discovered evidence nor does it cite any grave error of fact or law, or any serious irregularity, prejudicial to the interest of the respondents. In fact, the arguments propounded are in essence a mere reiteration of the arguments already scrutinized and exhaustively discussed,” the decision said.

The Consolidated Order reiterated that the officials should have ensured that all project documents were properly verified before the procurement and awarding process and the subsequent construction.

“They should have taken meticulous efforts to ensure that all documents were in order before the procurement and award of the project, and before the warehouse inside the questioned lot was constructed,” the decision stated.

With the denial of their motion for reconsideration, the Ombudsman sustained its finding of Gross Neglect of Duty and the corresponding six-month suspension without pay against all six officials.

Leave a Reply

Trending