
MANILA— Prosecutors at the International Criminal Court (ICC) have asked the court’s Trial Chamber III to reject a request from the defense team of former president Rodrigo Roa Duterte, arguing that it falls outside the scope of the chamber’s instructions and bypasses established procedures for challenging evidence.
In a response dated November 20, Acting Prosecutor Mame Mandiaye Niang said the prosecution was not taking a position on the underlying issue, which was redacted in the public version of the filing, but opposed the defense’s request for an order at the outset of the proceedings.
“The Defense’s request… goes well beyond the scope of the requested observations from the Chamber,” the prosecution stated in its filing. “It also contravenes the Rules of Procedure and Evidence and the protocol established by the Chamber regarding challenges to the admissibility of evidence.”
The prosecution cited Rule 64(1) of the ICC Rules of Procedure and Evidence and the chamber’s June 19 directions, which require parties to raise objections to the admissibility of evidence when it is presented before the judges.
“The Defence may therefore raise its alleged concerns… when it is submitted by the Prosecution instead of improperly couching the request in observations,” the filing added.
Niang also sought to correct what the prosecution described as an inaccurate argument raised by Duterte’s defense team. However, the relevant portions explaining the disputed submission and the prosecution’s response were withheld from the public version to protect confidential information involving a prosecution source.
The response was initially filed confidentially on November 13 before a redacted version was made public on November 20.
Trial Chamber III, which is handling The Prosecutor v. Rodrigo Roa Duterte, is composed of Presiding Judge Joanna Korner, Judge Keebong Paek, and Judge Nicolas Guillou.
In its submission, the prosecution ultimately asked the chamber to dismiss the defense request in limine, or at the outset, maintaining that any concerns over the admissibility of evidence should be raised through the procedures already established by the court.
Duterte faces three counts of crimes against humanity before the ICC and is scheduled to stand trial on November 30, 2026.




Leave a Reply